Mental Capacity Resource Centre
Chambers has developed an unrivalled set of resources for those seeking to apply and understand the Mental Capacity Act 2005, as well as to understand the place of mental capacity within the law more generally. This section of the website gathers together a range of resources (1) our Mental Capacity Reports, free, monthly, reports covering all areas of law and practice relating to the MCA; (2) our guidance notes, including on assessing and determining capacity and best interests; and (3) our caselaw database, which summarises and comments upon the cases decided by the Court of Protection (and other courts considering the MCA).
Scroll down the page for each of these, or use the filter to navigate rapidly to what most interests you (and also to see articles written by members of the Court of Protection team).
Search
Filter By
Mental Capacity Cases
Summary Re B (A Child: Complex Needs: Deprivation of Liberty) [2026] EWHC 2789 (Fam) represents a clear and detailed consideration and application of AGNI to those under 16. It represents the first in what Henke J (the lead judge for the National DoL list) has said will be a number of decisions relating to children and young people whose cases she heard in that list. The specific child in question, B, was 9, with diagnoses of Autism Spectrum Disorder and Global Developmental Delay and presented with complex behavioural, emotional and developmental needs. She had a detailed Behaviour Support Plan and [...]
Summary In ZZ (Deprivation of Liberty in the Public Interest) (No. 2) [2026] EWCOP 57 (T2), two questions arose: (1) was ZZ deprived of his liberty; and (2) in circumstances where the primary reason for the relevant restrictions were to secure the public interest, was any deprivation of liberty to which he was subject justified? The judgment is the latest in a long-running saga which has been to Tier 3 and back (see Local Authority A v ZZ [2024] EWCOP 21), concerning a man with a constellation of impairments and presenting significant risks to others). As to the first question, [...]
Given that the AGNI case started with a devolution reference from Northern Ireland, it is of interest that – so far – there have been no reported cases from that jurisdiction applying the case. One reason for this is that the Northern Ireland DoLS framework applies more broadly than the Anglo-Welsh one (so the ‘community DoL’ cases heard by the Court of Protection largely do not arise), and that challenges to authorisations under that framework are heard by the Review Tribunal, which does not publish its judgments. However, we now have a Northern Ireland High Court decision which considers AGNI, [...]
Summary This judgment followed on Irwin Mitchell Trust Corporation v PW & Anor [2024] EWCOP 16 ("the First Judgment") which concluded that the appointment by Irwin Mitchell Trust Corporation ("IMTC") of IM Asset Management Ltd ("IMAM") as investment manager for an individual, PW, was a breach of the self-dealing rule. This earlier decision affected 260 individuals whose deputyships were held by IMTC, and whose funds were managed by IMAM. Further hearings were held to consider the applications made by IMTC for retrospective and prospective ratification of these appointments; these applications were opposed by both the Official Solicitor and the Public [...]
Barts Health NHS Trust v CG [2026] EWCOP 55 (T3) is a relatively ‘routine’ serious medical treatment case, which Theis J identified was rightly brought because of the level of proposed restraint required both pre-operatively and post-operatively to secure the safe carrying out of keyhole surgery (an endoscopic transsphenoidal resection) on a 59 year old man, CG, suffering from a large pituitary macroadenoma. CG, who had a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia, consistently refused the procedure “aris[ing] from his fixed belief that he does not have a tumour and that his difficulties can be cured by obtaining a new pair of glasses.” [...]
Summary Whilst this judgment has no precedent value, as a judgment by a Tier 1 judge, it is a judgment which carries with it the weight of practical experience, Tribunal Judge Sharron being a fee paid judge alongside her practice as a Court of Protection barrister. AA was a young man aged 26, with learning disabilities, epilepsy and diabetes; he was non-verbal. He lived in a supported living placement, and at paragraph 15, TJ Sharron summarised the restrictions to which he was subject as including the following: a) AA is required to live at the supported living placement. He is [...]
Summary Section 20(3)(a) MCA 2005 provides that a deputy “may not be given powers with respect to […] the settlement of any of P’s property, whether for P’s benefit or for the benefit of others.” This decision of Chief Master Shuman shows what happens when that limit is ignored. Six discretionary settlements made by a property and affairs deputy in 2011, without an order of the Court of Protection, were declared void ab initio, together with associated loans of more than £2.7 million. Although the assets had been administered as trust property for many years, the beneficial interest in them had [...]
Summary In Zedra Trust Company (UK) Limited v Graham David Tustain [2026] EWHC 2578 (BP) (discussed above), Chief Master Shuman held that six discretionary settlements made in 2011 by Mr Tustain’s then property and affairs deputy were void ab initio, because the Court of Protection had never authorised them. The assets had remained Mr Tustain’s throughout, held for him on bare resulting trust. This second judgment deals with the consequences for the professional trustee (formerly Barclays Bank Trust Company Limited), which had administered the assets for about fifteen years on the wrong assumption that the trusts were valid. It sought relief from [...]
PK and MK were two Ps (twin sisters). The Official Solicitor acted, separately, for both sisters, and argued (in agreement with the local authority) that neither sister was deprived of their liberty; HHJ Burrows agreed, holding (at paragraph 17) that: There is no doubt that the setting in which PK and MK live is some way from the paradigm place of detention identified by the Supreme Court. It is a place in which both young women are as at home as could be possible for people with their needs and disabilities. They are able to personalise the placement. They are [...]
Summary[1] T was 25 with diagnoses of autism, ADHD, a speech and language disorder and personality disorder. In October 2024 his solicitor wrote to the local authority about his long-standing difficulties with relationships and sexual boundaries, and asked for input from a psychologist and from learning disability and autism specialists. The Care Act needs assessment completed on 13 December 2024 recorded that “T lacks capacity in understanding relationships/sexual relationships and boundaries of relationships,” although this information came from the placement provider; the assessor had not assessed capacity herself (paragraph 19). The legality of the Care Act assessment was challenged principally [...]


