Irwin Mitchell Trust Corporation v PW & Anor

20th October 2026

Judge

HHJ Hilder

Citation(s)

  • [2026] EWCOP 53 (T2)

Summary

This judgment followed on Irwin Mitchell Trust Corporation v PW & Anor [2024] EWCOP 16 (“the First Judgment”) which concluded that the appointment by Irwin Mitchell Trust Corporation (“IMTC”) of IM Asset Management Ltd (“IMAM”) as investment manager for an individual, PW, was a breach of the self-dealing rule.  This earlier decision affected 260 individuals whose deputyships were held by IMTC, and whose funds were managed by IMAM.  Further hearings were held to consider the applications made by IMTC for retrospective and prospective ratification of these appointments; these applications were opposed by both the Official Solicitor and the Public Guardian.

Since the First Judgment, the Irwin Mitchell Group had sold IMAM, such that HHJ Hilder considered that, from 30th May 2027, the conflict of interest which gave rise to the First Judgment will no longer exist. in respect of prospective ratification:

(a) the parties have agreed, and the Court has authorised by order made on 4th May 2026, a scheme which ‘manages’ the conflict in so far as it continues until 30th May 2027 in respect of 260 other persons for whom either IMTC or an individual employee of the Irwin Mitchell Group acts as property and affairs deputy;

(b) in respect of PW herself, the positions of the parties are not crystallised, pending determination of the retrospective ratification issue.

This further judgment was divided into issues relating to the prospective ratification agreement and retrospective ratification.

Prospective: The issues around prospective ratification did not consider PW’s circumstances, but the other 260 individuals “for whom either the Applicant Trust Corporation or an individual employee of the Irwin Mitchell Group is currently appointed as property and affairs deputy and as such has appointed IMAM as investment manager. Notwithstanding the sale of IMAM, the prospective ratification question still arises for these 260 individuals because of the terms of the sale agreement” (paragraph 17). The details of the sale were not set out due to commercial sensitivity, but the court and parties “considered that the terms of sale of IMAM mean that there is potential for a continuation of the breach of the self-dealing rule until 30th May 2027” (paragraph 18).  The parties had agreed a scheme (and submitted it to the court for its approval) to manage this conflict of interests, “essentially that an Independent Financial Adviser with appropriate Court of Protection and personal injury expertise will conduct a high-level independent review of the general suitability of investment arrangements” (paragraph 20). For each of the 260 individuals, they and one person with an interest in their welfare were to be notified of this arrangement, along with the court’s order and an explanatory letter. The purpose of the scheme was temporary:

  1. In substance, this arrangement ‘holds the ring’ – managing the continuing conflict of interest for a defined period so as to avoid necessity for hurried reorganisation of many deputyships at once – until there can be full individual reviews in light of this judgment.

The retrospective ratification took place in respect of PW alone, but it would appear likely to be the basis of consideration of this issue in the other matters. Senior Judge Hilder noted the basis on which the court approached the matter:

  1. Retrospective ratification means the waiver by the Court of claims that PW has or may have against IMTC or IMAM in respect of the breach of the self-dealing rule. By agreement of all parties, I approach the decision whether or not to ratify on the basis of the following assumptions (“The Assumptions”), which have been set out in recital E to the order made on 7th June 2024:

(a) that the performance of PW’s investments during their period of management by IMAM have been such as would have been achieved by a reasonable and experienced investment manager; and

(b) that the fees and charges charged by IMAM in respect of PW during this period were such as would have been charged by a reasonable and experienced investment manager.

HHJ Hilder identified how, “because the Court is standing in the shoes of PW, it is possible for the Court to impose terms or conditions on any ratification. However, the person whose act may be ratified is not obliged to accept the terms or conditions. If the terms are not accepted, there is simply no ratification” (paragraph 28). PW did not have an understanding of the matters so as to be able to express wishes and feelings. PW’s husband was very positive about the work of the deputy, but raised a concern that he did not want to incur extra costs as a result of instructing IMAM as a fund manager (relative to other fund managers).

On behalf of PW, the Official Solicitor opposed a ‘blanket’ ratification, and wanted to consider whether PW was entitled to compensation. The Official Solicitor’s argument was set out at paragraph 34 of the judgment:

(a) ‘this is not, therefore, a case of an inadvertent breach of the strict self-dealing rules, rather it is a case where IM has quite deliberately – and in the face of the decision in Re MWS – grown a business model based upon the appointment of its own asset management business for incapacitated individuals.” [ps para 5]

(b) IMTC has not ‘only just discovered it has committed a technical breach….it has been (or ought to have been) aware since 2015 that the appointment of IMAM was a breach of the rule.’ The OS sees no justification for saying that such conduct is not deserving of sanction. [ps para 13]

The Official Solicitor considered that PW had claims with a real prospect of success against IMTC and IMAM, and did not consider that a waiver of the claims was of benefit to PW. The Official Solicitor considered that the likely quantum of such a claim was “all of the fees and charges levied by IMAM throughout its period as investment manager. From the evidence filed, for the period from IMAM’s appointment until the end of 2023 and not including the amount paid to third parties, this amounts to £37 647 [229] – “not a small sum of money” [ps para 9]” (paragraph 36). The Official Solicitor was open to the possibility of a commercial settlement to this claim (proposing a settlement for 70% of the claim in correspondence), but it was agreed by all parties that if ratification did not take place, IMTC would need to be removed as deputy as it would be infeasible to pursue these claims with IMTC as deputy. The Public Guardian fully aligned herself with the Official Solicitor.

IMTC accepted the conclusion of the 2024 judgment, and was clear that both IMTC and IMAM wished to preserve the relationship between PW and IMTC (and avoid litigation over these issues). They noted that neither PW nor her husband had strong views about this matter, and wished for the court to determine what should happen. IMTC raised concerns that the family had not been advised of the full range of outcomes of PW bringing proceedings, but had instead had the high-water mark of potential recovery figures in litigation put to them. IMTC considered the likely quantum of recovery was much lower than the total charges raised by IMAM, as allowances would be made for the expenditure incurred in realising profits for PW and the fiduciary’s own work and skill. PW’s recovery would not be “to punish the fiduciary but to prevent them from obtaining an advantage from their breach” (paragraph 47(b)(iii)).  IMTC noted that the likely profit was more in the range of £9,000-£9,500 over a six-year period, and that this would be the ‘ceiling’ of the claim. It was also emphasised (paragraph 47(f)) that:

this is not a case where there has been any dishonesty, bad faith or surreptitious dealing. IMAM worked diligently for PW’s benefit, providing full consideration for the fees that were charged. Had IMAM not been appointed, PW would still have incurred similar charges with an alternative investment manager. ‘This is a paradigm case for a generous allowance to be made for IMAM’s work and skill….such an allowance would either eliminate the claim entirely or (at best from PW’s perspective) reduce it to a very modest amount.’ [ps para 15(5)]

HHJ Hilder summarised IMTC’s position at paragraph 50:

Overall, IMTC’s primary position is that it is in the best interests of PW to provide retrospective ratification of its appointment of IMAM, without any terms/conditions, on the following grounds [ps para 16].

(a) it allows the deputyship relationship to continue;

(b) it is not in PW’s best interests to pursue uncertain litigation;

(c) drawing a line under the past breach of the self-dealing rule enables both parties to move on from the current situation;

(d) the conduct of IMTC and IMAM has been honest and reasonable, the connection between the two never hidden but disclosed in in annual deputyship reports; and the ‘reasonableness’ should therefore be considered in light of the fact that the OPG as statutory body responsible for supervision of deputies took no action about it because it accorded with policies the OPG was applying at the time;

(e) IMAM provided full consideration to PW for the fees and charges it rendered. Had a different investment manager been appointed, PW would have been paying similar fees. PW has not been disadvantaged in any way by the breach of the self-dealing rule;

(f) the resource implications of refusing ratification would have a direct, negative consequence for PW – “it cannot be in PW’s best interests to be placed in the position of requiring a new deputy if there are a large number of other Ps in a similar position at the same time, and insufficient deputies available to take up this work”.

In the event that the court was minded to grant ratification, IMTC proposed that this be in the amount of 75% of IMAM’s assessed profits, or approximately £6,750.

At paragraph 53, Senior Judge Hilder considered that the main issue around retrospective ratification was “dominated by [the parties’] different approaches to likely quantification of any claim which PW has against IMTC to account for profits gained as a result of the conflict of interest:

(a) IMTC says that such claim will be based on net profits ie payments received from PW minus VAT, third party disbursements, a share of IMAM overheads/expenses and an allowance for skill and care undertaken – “the profits approach“;

(b) the Official Solicitor (with the Public Guardian in alignment) says that such claim is based on net receipts ie payments received from PW minus VAT and third party disbursements but without any deduction for overheads/expenses and with very limited likelihood of any discretionary allowance for skill and care undertaken – “the receipts approach.”’ [53]

In PW’s case, the difference was approximately £18,500. HHJ Hilder did not reach a view on quantum, as this was not a matter for the Court of Protection, and noted that it was open to either party to make those arguments in the civil court. She did consider that PW “has a real claim, with real value (albeit presently unquantified) – and that is a factor which I must weigh in the balance when making a ‘best interests’ determination as to whether IMTC’s breach of the self-dealing rule should be ratified” (paragraph 56). Given that PW had significant assets, while the higher sum proposed by the Official Solicitor was significant, it was not “likely to be a life-altering one for PW” (paragraph 57).  However HHJ Hilder was also mindful that “[i]f IMTC’s approach were to find favour, the figure is so much lower that, bearing in mind the disruption to deputyship arrangements which would be required (see below), the compensation ‘victory’ might even be considered pyrrhic.”

Senior Judge Hilder considered that:

  1. […] the amount of compensation which PW may receive from her prospective claim weighs less heavily in the scales than the existence of the claim. That is, it is more important that PW’s claim is recognised than that it is pursued to its fullest possible extent. I count it as a factor against ratification that ratification would – at least unless some condition of compensation is attached – extinguish PW’s claim. And I give considerable weight to the position of PW’s own representatives in these proceedings, that her claim should not be given up.
  2. In the absence of ratification, I consider that PW is likely to be adversely affected to some extent, because a settled and positive relationship with her deputy will have to end. Dispute will continue and litigation be required. All parties accept that in those circumstances, IMTC could not continue to act as PW’s deputy. Even if, as her representatives in these proceedings contend, the further litigation itself need not impact on her day to day experience, getting to know a new deputy will. There is adversity in that, but how much?
  3. There would inevitably be some financial cost involved in changing deputy, whilst the new deputy ‘gets up to speed’ with the requirements of getting to know PW and managing her estate. Other detriments are likely too, in terms of confidence, morale, stress etc. The best indication of these comes from Mr. W’s observations to the Official Solicitor’s representative, as outlined above. He does not want his wife to lose out, but neither is it for them simply a monetary consideration – their past relationship with Irwin Mitchell is valued…. I conclude that changing deputyship would incur some financial cost for PW and some disruption, but not so much as to amount to a ‘magnetic factor’ in the Court’s determination.’

Senior Judge Hilder ultimately included a balance sheet table to weigh up the different factors:

 

A. In favour of ratificationB. Against ratificationC. Not to be weighed
1. Continuation of existing deputyship relationship1. Gives up claim of real (unquantified) monetary value
– recognition more important than (unquantified) amount
1. Punitive sanction
2. End of dispute and associated uncertainty
– level of disruption not so great as to amount to the magnetic factor
2. PW’s her legal representatives oppose ratification
– PW and her husband consider that court should decide
2. Resource implications
3. The Assumptions
– no loss caused to PW’s estate

 

Senior Judge Hilder stated that she was “not persuaded that any of the factors in column A, either individually or collectively, justify complete abandonment of PW’s potential claim, contrary to the considered position of her legal representatives. Therefore, IMTC’s primary position does not succeed” (paragraph 67). However, these factors “do carry sufficient weight to conclude that the Court should do what it can to bring about a situation where both PW’s claim is recognised and the positive deputyship relationship is maintained, which is her representatives’ preferred outcome. The mechanism for that is conditional ratification. In my view, it would be in PW’s best interests that IMTC’s past breach is ratified on condition that IMTC pays back into PW’s funds an appropriate amount to recognise her claim” (paragraph 68).

Senior Judge Hilder considered that the ‘receipts’ approach was the method to be adopted, “because that is the methodology preferred by PW’s own representatives. They have very considerable experience, and their position is that they serve PW’s interests best by pursuing her claim on this methodology, even at the potential cost of disrupted deputyship” (paragraph 70). However, “the discount should be more than 30%, because that has already been insufficient to produce agreement, which suggests some risk that IMTC may choose not to accept the condition. The discount should be not so far less than the Official Solicitor’s open position that the reasoning of PW’s representatives is lost, but it should be sufficiently less that IMTC now sees merit in accepting the condition. In my view, both considerations should be met by a reduction of 40%” (paragraph 70), leaving the ratification open to IMTC at 60% of the higher valuation of calculating the claim. If IMTC did not accept this, Senior Judge Hilder found that “its appointment as property and affairs deputy for PW must be discharged so that PW’s claims in respect of the unratified breach of the self-dealing rule can be pursued elsewhere” (paragraph 71). Questions of prospective ratification would only arise if the retrospective ratification were accepted, and Senior Judge Hilder set a timetable for IMTC to give this notification, along with inviting the parties to suggest a timetable for seeking relevant directions in respect of the 260 or so other cases raising the same issues.

Comment

It was inevitable given the First Judgment that IMTC was going to be in for (to use a technical term) a rocky time of it.  The decision by Irwin Mitchell group to sell the ‘offending’ IMAM was also perhaps an inevitable consequence of the judgment.  What we do not know at the time of writing is whether IMTC had, in fact, agreed to the conditions imposed by Senior Judge Hilder.  If they have not, and if matters are then potentially taken to another jurisdiction on PW’s behalf, it will be interesting to see whether the veil of privacy around what would ordinarily be highly confidential matters will continue to be pierced (it would, for instance, be highly unlikely that any compromise agreement endorsed pursuant to CPR Part 21 by the civil courts in litigation in the former Chancery Division would be made public).

Latest Cases

Sign up to Our Thinking

Sign up now to receive our latest newsletters, legal insights and information on upcoming events.