Omani Supreme Court Holds Omani Courts Cannot Annul London-Seated ICC Award

19th November 2026

Vijay Tanks & Partners LLC v Galfar Al Misnad Engineering & Contracting LLC — Supreme Court Appeal No. 745/8103/2026 (19 May 2026)

Madelaine Power (39 Essex Chambers) and Sultan Al Ghafri, Nasser Al Riyami and Abdullah Al Aufi (K&Co Oman)

On 19 May 2026, the Omani Supreme Court held that the Omani courts have no jurisdiction to annul an award made in a foreign-seated arbitration, unless the parties agreed to apply the Omani Arbitration Law (Royal Decree 47/1997). This is welcome news for creditors holding a foreign award against an Omani party: any challenge to the award must be brought in the courts of the seat, leaving the Omani courts to deal with recognition and enforcement.

The decision marks a clear shift from the Supreme Court’s approach three years ago, in a case involving the same award debtor.

2023: Supreme Court Allows Annulment Action Against London Award (Cape East v Vijay Tanks)

In Cape East v Vijay Tanks, the award debtor challenged a London-seated ICC award before the Muscat Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal declined jurisdiction. The Supreme Court disagreed. It relied on Article 29 of the Civil and Commercial Procedures Law and on Vijay Tanks being an Omani company to find that the Omani courts could hear the annulment action, and it remitted the case (see Global Arbitration Review, ‘Omani Supreme Court allows review of London award’, 26 October 2023). The challenge was ultimately dismissed when it returned to the Supreme Court in November 2024, but the episode left open the possibility of Omani parties challenging foreign awards at home.

2026: Supreme Court Declines Jurisdiction Over Galfar Award (Vijay Tanks v Galfar Al Misnad)

In November 2024, Galfar Al Misnad obtained an ICC award against Vijay Tanks in a separate London-seated arbitration. The award was recognised and enforced in Oman. Vijay Tanks then brought an annulment action before the Muscat Court of Appeal, which declined jurisdiction in March 2026. The Supreme Court declared Vijay Tanks’ appeal (Appeal No. 745/8103/2026) inadmissible, ordering it to pay the costs and forfeiting its security deposit.

The Court’s Reasoning

The Court reasoned as follows:

  1. Article 1 limits the reach of the Law. Article 1 begins by preserving the effect of international conventions in force in Oman, which include the New York Convention. It then applies the Arbitration Law to only two kinds of arbitration: those conducted in Oman, and international commercial arbitrations conducted abroad whose parties have agreed to apply the Law. The Court held that the legislator deliberately limited the Law in this way, so it does not extend to every arbitration held abroad. A foreign-seated arbitration comes within the Law only if the parties have opted in.
  2. Party autonomy. The Court linked this to the parties’ freedom of choice. Where parties agree to arbitrate under an institution, that institution’s rules govern the procedure. The parties may also agree the substantive rules, which the tribunal must apply. By choosing arbitration, the parties chose not to go to the ordinary courts. They chose their arbitrators, the procedure and the substantive law, and the Court’s reasoning gives effect to those choices.
  3. The seat is key. The Court treated the place of arbitration as the key factor, because it decides whether an award is domestic or foreign. That classification identifies the courts with jurisdiction over matters connected with the arbitration, the court competent to hear a challenge to the award, and the procedure for enforcement. In our view, this means that whether an Omani court has supervisory jurisdiction depends on where the arbitration was seated, not on who the parties are.
  4. Applying this to the facts. Clause 18 of the subcontract provided for ICC arbitration, with the laws of England and Wales governing the arbitration, London as the seat, English as the language, and an award that would be final and binding. Two other features did not affect the result. After consulting the parties under Article 18(2) of the ICC Rules, the sole arbitrator was allowed to hold meetings and deliberate anywhere, or by video. The tribunal also applied Qatari law to the merits. The Court did not treat either point as moving the seat, which remained London.
  5. Conclusion. The Omani courts have no jurisdiction to hear an action to annul a foreign award that falls outside the Arbitration Law, where the parties have not agreed to apply the Arbitration Law. The Court of Appeal had applied the law correctly, so the appeal had no basis.

Two further points are worth noting. First, the Court dealt with the appeal summarily, in the deliberation chamber under Article 248(2) of the Civil and Commercial Procedures Law, before the appeal was served on Galfar. Second, the judgment makes no mention of Vijay Tanks’ Omani nationality or of Article 29, which were the basis of the 2023 decision.

What It Means for Enforcement

  1. A delay tactic is closed off. An Omani award debtor is unlikely to be able to hold up enforcement by starting a parallel annulment action in Oman against a foreign-seated award. Vijay Tanks tried this in both cases.
  2. The approach is consistent with the New York Convention. Oman has been a party to the Convention since 1999 (Royal Decree 36/98). Setting an award aside is for the courts of the country in which, or under the law of which, the award was made (Article V(1)(e)). In Oman, the second limb corresponds to the Article 1 opt-in: only where the parties have chosen the Arbitration Law can the Omani courts hear a challenge to a foreign-seated award. An enforcing court applies only the Convention’s limited grounds for refusal.
  3. Party autonomy is respected. Omani courts will give effect to the parties’ choices of seat, rules and law. That gives confidence to parties arbitrating abroad against Omani counterparties. It equally gives confidence to parties who choose Muscat or the Oman Commercial Arbitration Centre, knowing the Omani courts will supervise their awards.

Latest Insights

Sign up to Our Thinking

Sign up now to receive our latest newsletters, legal insights and information on upcoming events.