Episodes
Latest
Contested Heritage #20: Syrian Cultural Heritage
Authors:
The work of restoring Syria’s cultural heritage after years of wartime looting goes beyond the antiquities trade. Richard Harwood KC of 39 Essex Chambers and Clarissa Levi of BHL Art Group talk to intelligence expert Anwar Darkazally of Field I...
Read more
Contested Heritage #19: Pilgrimage Routes
Authors:
What was it to be a pilgrim? How has pilgrimage continued over the centuries and how authentic are our modern pilgrim ways? Richard Harwood KC of 39 Essex Chambers and Clarissa Levi of BHL Art Group chat to Dr Emma Wells. Emma is the Head of Historic...
Read more
Contested Heritage #18: Keeping the Castle
Authors:
What are the joys and challenges of life in a castle? Richard Harwood KC of 39 Essex Chambers and Clarissa Levi of BHL Art Group speak with Charles Berkeley of Berkeley Castle about combining a family home and business, and looking to the future afte...
Read more
Contested Heritage #17: Artificial Intelligence and Art
Authors:
How does Artificial Intelligence affect art and cultural institutions? Richard Harwood KC of 39 Essex Chambers and Clarissa Levi of BHL Art Group talk to Emily Gould, Assistant Director of the Institute of Art and Law, to discuss the use of creative ...
Read more
Contested Heritage #16: Heritage Foundations
Authors:
39 Essex Chambers barristers Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi of BHL Group talk to Lucy Brown, Chief Executive of the Hugo Burge Foundation, about setting up an arts foundation. We explore how the founder’s vision became a reality, and the gifts ...
Read more
Contested Heritage #15: Art and Land
Authors:
When is an artwork part of a building or land? Or can you just take the statue with you when you sell up? Dr David Sawtell, barrister at 39 Essex Chambers, talks to Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi from BHL Art Group about Henry Moore sculpture i...
Read more
Contested Heritage #14: What do historic buildings and art mean to the historian?
Authors:
We often talk of the historic interest in buildings, but what does that mean to the historian? How does art help understand our past? Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi from BHL Art Group talk to Dr Elizabeth Norton, a historian specialising in the...
Read more
Contested Heritage #13: The Economic of Heritage
Authors:
How is the viability of a heritage project considered? When do the numbers stack up?Richard Harwood KC of 39 Essex Chambers and Clarissa Levi of BHL Art Group talk to David Tomback OBE FRICS, the Development Economics Director of Historic England abo...
Read more
Contested Heritage #12: The Parthenon Marbles Dispute
Authors:
What are the Parthenon Marbles? Were they lawfully removed from the Acropolis in Athens by Lord Elgin’s agents in the early Nineteenth Century? What ethical issues arise by their retention at the British Museum? How might the dispute be resolved?
39...
Read more
Contested Heritage #11: Funding our Heritage
Authors:
What do we value from our past, and how do we fund it? 39 Essex Chambers barrister Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi from BHL Art Group discuss the impact of lottery funding on the UK’s heritage landscape, the additionality principle, and if we sh...
Read more
Contested Heritage #10: The Fate of Looted Art
Authors:
What became of the art once owned by Jewish collectors in Nazi Europe? Restitution expert Richard Aronowitz explains his work in provenance research in the commercial art world, finding “just and fair solutions” for looted art.
Read more
Contested Heritage #9: Caring for Cultural Heritage
Authors:
In her new book Dr Charlotte Woodhead explores the legal and ethical initiatives in the UK for caring for cultural heritage. 39 Essex Chambers barrister Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi discuss ethics of care and the appropriate care for our heri...
Read more
Contested Heritage #8: The Business of Exhibitions
Authors:
Museum exhibitions are creatures of business…” 39 Essex Chambers member Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi talk to Anthony Misquitta of the V&A and Keystone Law. They discuss what makes an exhibition a success, and the commercial importance of ...
Read more
Hot Topics Episode 7: Demystifying Noise Evidence - with Rupert Thornely Taylor - Part 2
Authors:
Noise impacts are an issue which often crops up as part of planning and infrastructure applications either because the development applied for is noisy or the environment into which it is proposed to be introduced is noisy. The evidence is often comp...
Read more
Hot Topics Episode 6: Demystifying Noise Evidence - with Rupert Thornely Taylor - Part 1
Authors:
Noise impacts are an issue which often crops up as part of planning and infrastructure applications either because the development applied for is noisy or the environment into which it is proposed to be introduced is noisy. The evidence is often comp...
Read more
Contested Heritage #7: Heritage Uncovered
Authors:
To live in historic homes we must keep them modernised. This needn’t mean a loss - updating a home for modern living can reveal and celebrate its heritage. Also… we need bathrooms! 39 Essex Chambers member Richard Harwood and Claris...
Read more
Contested Heritage #6: Mixing Art and Law
Authors:
How do lawyers relax? Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi chat to Stephen Tromans KC, one of the country’s leading environmental lawyers, about his painting and his works recently exhibited at 39 Essex Chambers.
The catalogues for two of the collec...
Read more
Contested Heritage #5: Barts Heritage
Authors:
The restoration of the Great Hall and Hogarth Staircase at St Bartholomew’s Hospital in the City of London is one of the most exciting conservation projects presently underway. Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi talk to Will Palin, Chief Executive ...
Read more
Contested Heritage #4: Curating our heritage
Authors:
The Acceptance in Lieu scheme allows Inheritance Tax to be paid with art. Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi talk to Professor Frances Fowle of the University of Edinburgh and Scottish National Galleries. They discuss an important collection of pai...
Read more
Hot Topics Episode 5: Going Nuclear - An Overview of Nuclear Law with Stephen Tromans KC
Authors:
In this episode Tora Hutton and and Stephen Tromans KC discuss ‘Nuclear Law’. The discussion starts with the existential question of whether Nuclear Law exists. Happily, they decide it does and go on to discuss the ins and outs of this technical area...
Read more
Hot Topics Episode 4: How should Greenhouse Gas Emissions be Cumulatively Assessed?
Authors:
In this episode Tora Hutton and Rose Grogan discuss the Court of Appeal’s decision in R(oao Boswell) v Secretary of State for Transport [2024] EWCA CIv 145 which considered the lawfulness of the Secretary of State’s approach to the cumulative assessm...
Read more
Contested Heritage #3: The Heritage Industry - Heaven or Hell?
Authors:
How heritage consultants help, retro-fitting and the three characteristics of Gothic architecture. Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi chat to Dr Emma Wells, Head of Historic Buildings at SLR Consulting about big issues in heritage advice and compet...
Read more
Contested Heritage #2: The British Country House Revival
Authors:
Most of Britain’s heritage is cared for by private owners. Richard Harwood KC and Clarissa Levi talk to Ben Cowell OBE, the Director General of Historic Houses. They discuss the threats to country houses and their safeguarding over the last 50 years,...
Read more
Contested Heritage #1: Introduction
Authors:
In this new podcast subseries 'Contested Heritage', presented to you by Richard Harwood KC of 39 Essex Chambers and Clarissa Levi of BHL Art Group discuss challenges and successes in the heritage and art world with guests from across the sector. For ...
Read more
Hot Topics Episode 3: Housing for key workers, is this the new affordable housing model?
Authors:
Tora Hutton is joined by Paul Stinchcombe KC and Ian Parker of McPartland Planning to discuss their recent success in promoting an appeal scheme for affordable housing for key workers in the Green Belt. They consider whether this approach is likely t...
Read more
Hot Topics Episode 2: Is there now momentum in favour of housing appeals in the green belt being allowed? - A St Albans case study
Authors:
Tora Hutton is joined by Paul Stinchcombe KC of 39 Essex Chambers to discuss whether recent appeal decisions mean that there is now momentum in favour of grants of planning permission for residential development in the Green Belt. They look at St Alb...
Read more
Hot Topics in Planning and Environmental Law - Episode 1: Introduction
Authors:
In this podcast subseries Tora Hutton interviews fellow members of 39 Essex Chambers and special guests on hot topics in the planning and environmental space. Each episode will focus on a discrete subject. Whether the focus is an important judgment, ...
Read more
Lobbying Councillors: Writing to the Committee
Authors:
In the second in his short series on lobbying councillors, Richard Harwood QC looks at how, when and what to write when making representations to councillors.
Read more
Planning and the way out of Lockdown for Hospitality
Authors:
What can cafes, restaurants, pubs and attractions do to increase trade outdoors as lockdown eases? More space? Marquees? Richard Harwood QC looks at the planning and pavement licensing rules that apply.
Read more
When Fixation Becomes Legal Irrationality
Authors:
In this episode John Pugh-Smith looks at the circumstances in which this ground of challenge was upheld by Mrs Justice Lang in R(United Trade Action Group) v Transport for London and Mayor of London [2021] EWHC 72...
Read more
EqIAs: Ignore their significance at your peril
Authors:
In this episode, John Pugh-Smith looks at Equalities Impact Assessments (EqIAs) in the context of planning and traffic schemes, highlighted by the recent High Court success of the London Taxi Drivers in their challenge to the Mayor's Stree...
Read more
Lessons To Be Learned From "That" Parish Council Meeting
Authors:
In this episode, John Pugh-Smith discusses the procedural issues surrounding Handforth's Parish Council's infamous Zoom meeting.
Read more
Pension Schemes and Climate Change – a discussion of the new changes
Authors:
In this episode, Katherine Apps and Gethin Thomas discuss the Pensions Schemes Bill 2019, passed through Parliament on 19 January 2019, which create regulation making powers to impose governance and information publication duties on pension schemes i...
Read more
Can you lobby councillors?
Authors:
In the first of a short series on lobbying councillors, Richard Harwood QC looks at the Holborn Studios (No2) judgment and asks the fundamental question: is there a right to communicate directly with elected politicians?
Read more
Planning Court Reform
Authors:
In this episode, Richard Harwood QC considers the four different ways of bringing proceedings in the Planning Court and asks whether four should become one.
Read more
That ADR Feeling
Authors:
In this episode John Pugh-Smith considers this topic in the context of the current round of consultation on changes to the Judicial Review: the Government commissioned Faulks' Independent Review of Administrative Law (which closed on 26th October) an...
Read more
Openness in a year of Lockdowns
Authors:
In this episode John Pugh-Smith reviews the Higher Courts cases on the correct approach to this Green Belt thorny issue, starting with the Supreme Court's judgment in R (Samuel Smith Old Brewery (Tadcaster) Ltd) v North Yorkshire County Council...
Read more
That Technical Traps Submission - John Pugh-Smith
Authors:
In this episode John Pugh-Smith, wearing his hat as an arbitrator and neutral dispute resolver, discusses the significance of the recent case of Norfolk Homes Ltd v North Norfolk DC [2020] EWHC 2265 (QB) on the interpretation of Section 106...
Read more
An Opportunity Not to Be Missed Again - John Pugh-Smith
Authors:
In this episode John Pugh-Smith FSA FCIArb, a leading mediator and promoter of the use of its facilitative techniques in the planning and compensation systems, discusses how it can be utilised not just to help the Government deliver the intentions be...
Read more
Cold War - with Richard Harwood KC
Authors:
In this episode, Richard discusses the planning battle over a relic of the Cold War in Cambridge and asks what does it tell us about ourselves?
Read more
Controlling Demolition in Planning and the Save Britain's Heritage Lancaster Case - Richard Harwood OBE KC
Authors:
In this podcast, Richard Harwood QC looks at how planning law finally took control over the demolition of buildings. In 2009 the former Mitchell's Brewery site was the subject of an epic battle as SAVE Britain's Heritage fought to save it, chal...
Read more
A short history of short cuts in the planning system
Authors:
In this podcast, Richard Harwood QC looks at the numerous ways of obtaining planning consent without making a planning application to the local authority and asks, how far have development orders and zoning been used?
Read more