Cases

AXX v Zajac (Vulnerable parties - Article 6 ECHR - PD1A - case management - split trial - disability - brain injury - personal injury - psychosis - PTSD - mental health - Equal Treatment Bench Book - adjustments)

Summary  The judgment of Master McCloud in AXX v Zajac is the first reported judgment concerning the provisions of CPR PD1A, concerning vulnerable litigants.  It is a model in two ways.   Firstly, it contains a plain language summary at the outset f... Read more  
 
Other proceedings - Civil

Newcastle Upon Tyne NHS Foundation Trust v MB

Summary This case concerns the medical treatment of MB, a 30-year-old man suffering from neuropsychiatric symptoms. In May 2022 he was given a working diagnosis, following a brain biopsy, of T-cell cancer of the skin, brain and bone marrow. The dise... Read more  
 
Best interests - Medical treatment

Guy's And St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust v A & Ors

 
Medical Treatment - Treatment Withdrawal

Traskunova v. Russia

In Traskunova v Russia, the Third Section of the Strasbourg Court revisited the issue of capacity and informed consent, this time in the context of experimental treatment and a breach of Article 2 ECHR.   The applicant’s daughter, Ms AT, died age 59... Read more  
 
Mental capacity - Medical treatment

Lincolnshire County Council v TGA & Ors

Summary In Lincolnshire County Council v TGA, a 14-year-old boy with epilepsy, autism, Attention Deficit Disorder and global developmental delay was accommodated by the local authority under s.20 of the Children Act 1989 with the consent of his test... Read more  
 
Article 5 ECHR - Children and young persons , Article 5 ECHR - Deprivation of liberty

AC and GC (Capacity: Hoarding: Best Interests)

Summary In AC and GC, HHJ Clayton was concerned with two individuals: AC, 92, and her son, GC. The court considered whether they lacked capacity to make decisions about their items and belongings.  An application had been made for an order that AC ... Read more  
 
Best interests - Property and affairs , Care , Care

Re TT (Injunctive Relief)

Summary The court considered the best interests of TT, a 46-year-old man of Asian heritage with a diagnosis of a mild learning disability. TT lived with his parents until 2019, when he moved into a supported living accommodation. The case considered... Read more  
 
COP Jurisdiction and powers - Injunctions

Hull City Council v KF

Summary KF wanted to spend one last night with her long-term partner, days before he was due to be imprisoned for causing her grievous bodily harm. Given the absence of bail conditions, whether this could happen depended upon her capacity to make th... Read more  
 
Best interests - Contact , Mental capacity , Mental capacity - Sexual relations

XX v West Northamptonshire Council & Anor

XX was an 89-year-old man who had come from Jamaica to the UK to live and work in the 1960s. XX had been living in a care home since December 2020. An application was brought by AA, one of XX’s nieces, and asked the court to consider whether it is in... Read more  
 
Best interests - Residence

A Mental Health Trust v BG

Summary In A Mental Health Trust v BG, the court considered an application for declarations that BG lacked capacity to make decisions about her care and treatment, including nutrition and hydration, and that it was in BG’s best interests that no fur... Read more  
 
Best interests - Medical treatment

South Tyneside and Sunderland NHS Foundation Trust v SA

Summary This case concerned the medical treatment of SA, a 22 year old man with a diagnosis of Autistic Spectrum Disorder, Severe Learning Disabilities, Communication difficulties and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. Due to his needs SA has... Read more  
 
Best interests - Medical treatment

A NHS Foundation Trust v G and others

Summary A 27-year-old woman with a rare and profound degenerative neurological condition which affected the entirety of her central nervous system had been in hospital since 2008. The condition was progressive and was neither receptive to treatment ... Read more  
 
COP Jurisdiction and powers - Injunctions